Shall we play a game? An AI experiment...

gondar1

gondar1

I'm kind of a big deal in Japan
Trusted Member
Propose a question or inquiry to an AI.
Name the AI and quote the question EXACTLY.
Next person Proposes EXACTLY the same question and we compare answers.
I think I did this before to some extent and the answers were different, IDK why that would be.
I suggest to start with a clean slate by using these words to open "I have a new subject."

I'll go first :
To Grok - "I have a new subject. In ten words or less, what is the meaning of life"
A: "To seek truth, love, and purpose in our existence."

PS - Please keep in mind this is interesting to me but it's also yet another area I arnt smart in. I have no idea what happens inside these magical boxes I type on. I have one that I can see inside of and there is no sign of a hamster wheel or a tiny magician pulling strings, only some wires and lights and a few things that get really hot to the touch
 
gondar1 said:
Propose a question or inquiry to an AI.
Name the AI and quote the question EXACTLY.
Next person Proposes EXACTLY the same question and we compare answers.
I think I did this before to some extent and the answers were different, IDK why that would be.
I suggest to start with a clean slate by using these words to open "I have a new subject."

I'll go first :
To Grok - "I have a new subject. In ten words or less, what is the meaning of life"
A: "To seek truth, love, and purpose in our existence."

PS - Please keep in mind this is interesting to me but it's also yet another area I arnt smart in. I have no idea what happens inside these magical boxes I type on. I have one that I can see inside of and there is no sign of a hamster wheel or a tiny magician pulling strings, only some wires and lights and a few things that get really hot to the touch
Click to expand...
I run speech ideas through chat gpt and when I've asked the exact same query multiple times, I've gotten all different speeches. Most very well written, personal, and then the option to add specific points or concepts which rewrites it to include the expanded parameters, like life events, names etc

Pretty insane, and virtually instantaneous

Total hack for a quick, successful and easy wedding speech if you're ever unlucky enough to be asked to do one for someone 😆
 
Another one please, suspect this one will show more about input etc

Grok
"new subject. what started the current war in Ukraine?"

A: "Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022, started the current war, driven by geopolitical tensions, NATO expansion concerns, and Putin’s aim to control Ukraine’s sovereignty. Historical disputes, like Crimea’s 2014 annexation, and Russia’s support for separatists in Donbas escalated the conflict."
 
ChatGPT

The current war in Ukraine, which began in February 2022, was sparked by Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine. The roots of the conflict go back years, but key immediate triggers include:

1. Russia’s Claims and Demands: Russia opposed Ukraine's growing ties with the West—especially its aspirations to join NATO—and claimed it needed to protect Russian-speaking populations in eastern Ukraine.


2. Russian Recognition of Separatist Regions: Just days before the invasion, Russia formally recognized the self-proclaimed independence of two separatist regions in eastern Ukraine (Donetsk and Luhansk), where fighting had already been ongoing since 2014.


3. Invasion on February 24, 2022: Russia launched a large-scale military attack across Ukraine, including missile strikes and ground assaults, aiming to overthrow the Ukrainian government and assert control over the country.



The conflict has since become a prolonged and devastating war, with global consequences.

Would you like a breakdown of the earlier events since 2014 as well?
 
I asked perplexity, and got similar answers as above.

Then asked it to answer the question again but to remain neutral and source citations from both sides.


The current war in Ukraine began with Russia’s full-scale invasion on February 24, 2022. The causes are deeply rooted in both recent events and long-running disputes over security, sovereignty, and the post-Cold War order.

Russian Perspective
Security Assurances and NATO Expansion: Russian leaders, including Vladimir Putin, argue that Western officials gave clear assurances in 1990–91 that NATO would not expand eastward beyond Germany. Declassified documents show that U.S. Secretary of State James Baker and other Western leaders told Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev that NATO would move “not one inch eastward,” and similar statements were made by leaders from Germany, the UK, and France. Russia sees NATO’s subsequent enlargement-including the possibility of Ukraine joining-as a betrayal of these assurances and a direct threat to Russian security.

Sphere of Influence: Russia has long viewed Ukraine as part of its traditional sphere of influence and considers Western involvement in Ukraine’s politics and security as encroachment.

Western Perspective
Nature of Assurances: Western officials and historians generally maintain that while verbal assurances were made about NATO’s role in East Germany during reunification, there was no formal, binding agreement to prevent NATO expansion into Eastern Europe. The 1990 treaty on German reunification did not contain language ruling out NATO enlargement, and Western leaders later insisted that each country has the sovereign right to choose its alliances.

Ukrainian Sovereignty: The West views Russia’s invasion as unprovoked aggression against a sovereign nation. They argue that Ukraine, as an independent country, has the right to seek its own security arrangements, including closer ties with NATO and the EU.

Scholarly and Historical Debate
Ambiguity and Misunderstanding: The historical record shows that there were discussions and informal assurances, but no binding treaty. Some scholars and diplomats argue that the Soviets were led to believe NATO would not expand, while others say the assurances were limited to Germany and not intended as a blanket promise for all of Eastern Europe.

Impact on Relations: This ambiguity has fueled Russian grievances and mistrust, which Putin has cited as justification for military action in Ukraine.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top